QualityInspection.org

Quality Assurance, Product Development, and Purchasing Strategies in China

  • Home
  • Articles
    • An Importer’s Guide to New Product Manufacturing in China
  • Best Of
  • About Us
  • Contact us
X

Don't miss a post

It's easy to subscribe to our newsletter where you'll receive weekly updates for professional importers and manufacturers on better understanding, controlling, and improving manufacturing & supply chain in China.

You are here: Home / Supplier Management / Imposing fines on Chinese suppliers

Imposing fines on Chinese suppliers

March 28, 2012

Supplier ManagementLast week I received this question from a reader:

What are your thoughts about imposing fines on suppliers for late delivery and quality issues? Does it work or just causes more problems ?

My short answer is: yes it can work, but only if it is structured correctly.

You don’t want penalties to be so harsh that it seems unfair. But you want a system that has teeth.

Example: fine for late shipments:

Many buyers write something like: “5% penalty for each week behind schedule; after 2 weeks late the supplier will have to send the whole order by airfreight or the order will be canceled”.

Another option is this: “4% penalty for 1 week late, total 10% penalty for 2 weeks late, total 25% penalty for 3 weeks late, total 50% penalty for 4 weeks late”.

Example: fine for failed QC inspection:

In case of a failed QC inspection on your products, you can probably ask for a discount of 500 USD (usually the QC inspection will cost you around 300 USD, so that’s what you’ll have to pay for a re-inspection).

Of course, it should be included in the quality control plan you give the suppliers for signature (before issuing purchase orders).

Should you apply these penalties?

Not all importers can do it. There are actually 2 situations.

If you sometimes ask favors from suppliers (for example, if you change the specs at the last minute but you ask for the shipment date to be unchanged), you can’t hold them to a very high standard. In case the factory had some problems, told you in advance, showed some goodwill… You should be flexible.

If you are very organized on your side (which I strongly encourage) and you want your suppliers to live up to their promises: penalties should be systematically applied. They become anticipated by the supplier.

—

Related reading:

Using penalties effectively

Relationships with Chinese suppliers: be clean!

Filed Under: Supplier Management

Comments

  1. Renaud Anjoran says

    March 28, 2012 at 10:19 PM

    Veronika,
    Very true. Of course, if the buyer is begging for a supplier to accept his orders, there is no room for fines or QC inspection or anything sensible… Better avoid these deals.

  2. Veronika says

    March 28, 2012 at 10:10 PM

    Hello Renaud, nice post as always..!
    I’d say it also depends on the buying power of the importer. If the order quantity and value is high, the supplier has a lot of motivation to abide by the terms.
    Looking forward to the next great post!
    Veronika

  3. Peter Keller says

    March 29, 2012 at 6:36 AM

    Renaud,

    Always good blogs. Here is my experience- I managed from $100k to >$20M (annually) in buys from Chinese factories.

    It was always straight-forward to impose fines for re-inspection when the goods failed the first inspection. If the factory pushed back, we stood firm and in every case the factory relented and paid the re-inspection fee. In fact, we typically had the factory pay the inspection company directly.

    As for delays in production, this was more difficult. In many cases, the factory would know that we needed the goods, even if they were late, so they would refuse the fine. It’s a good idea, though- especially if you have the power advantage over the factory.

    Cheers!

  4. Renaud Anjoran says

    March 29, 2012 at 9:33 AM

    Peter,
    Asking the supplier to pay re-inspections is quite standard. But sometimes the supplier will say “we’ll only pay 100 USD for it because that’s all we think is reasonable – you pay the rest.”
    You are right, late penalties are more difficult to enforce.

  5. Eric says

    April 19, 2012 at 12:19 PM

    I think punishment ‘MUST’ and they will consider serious.  ( by the way, it should be BIG orders at factory for that )

    • Renaud Anjoran says

      April 19, 2012 at 11:11 PM

      Yes, I agree Eric. It is possible, for big orders.


Weekly updates for professional importers on better understanding, controlling, and improving manufacturing & supply chain in China.

This is the official blog of Sofeast.com.

This blog is written by Renaud Anjoran, an ASQ Certified Quality Engineer who has been involved in chinese manufacturing since 2005.

Hit the button below to get in touch:

Contact Us!

Subscribe to our email newsletter

Connect with us

  • Email
  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
sofeast
sofeast
sofeast

Latest Articles

  • Going from 1 Prototype to Mass Production directly is Dangerous
  • Should North American Importers Leave China For Countries Like Mexico or Vietnam? (Feat. Andrew Hupert) [Podcast]
  • Inspecting Productions with Very Few Defects: Dump the AQL
  • Answering Your Questions on Fabric Quality, US Tariffs, & Volatile Material Prices.
  • QMS Implementation Consultant vs. Certifying Body

Categories

  • Quality Control Tips
  • Sourcing New Suppliers
  • Supplier Management
  • New Product Development
  • Process Improvement
  • Ethical Sourcing

Archives

© 2022 QualityInspection.org